Attorney: Margaret Bryant

Take-Nothing Summary Judgment for Chemical Plant Owner Affirmed on Appeal

In a per curiam opinion, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has affirmed summary judgment in favor of Ware Jackson’s client, a chemical manufacturer, on premises liability claims asserted by an employee of an independent contractor who had sought over $10 million for injuries he sustained while working on the client’s premises. The Fifth Circuit agreed with the lower court that Ware Jackson’s client had no knowledge of any dangerous condition on its premises and that the client did not control the independent contractor’s activities. It also affirmed the exclusion of the plaintiff’s expert’s opinion regarding the premises owner’s knowledge.

Michelle Blair was lead appellate counsel and presented the oral argument. Paul Smith, Margaret Bryant, and Simone Dawson assisted with the appeal and helped secure the victory in the district court. The appellate opinion is: George v. SI Group, Inc., No. 25-40286, 2026 WL 1985321 (5th Cir. July 9, 2026).

Complete Defense Verdict from Fort Worth Jury in Water Code Dispute

Avery Sheppard, Margaret Bryant, and Jordan Parker secured a complete defense verdict for their client after a week-long jury trial in the 96th Judicial District Court of Tarrant County, Texas. The plaintiffs alleged that construction activities undertaken by Ware Jackson’s client, a residential real estate developer, altered the flow of surface and subsurface water on their neighboring property. They sued for violations of the Texas Water Code, trespass, intentional nuisance, negligence, and gross negligence, and sought millions of dollars for alleged damage to structures, loss of property value, mental anguish, and punitive damages.  After a week-long trial, the jury returned a verdict in favor of Ware Jackson’s client, finding that the plaintiffs were 100% negligent and suffered no damages.

Premises Liability Claim Against Chemical Manufacturer Dismissed on Summary Judgment

A federal district court has granted summary judgment and dismissed a premises liability claim that sought over $10 million from a chemical manufacturer represented by Ware Jackson. The court held the plaintiff was injured because of decisions made by his employer, over which Ware Jackson’s client did not exercise control, and that the client had no knowledge of any dangerous condition on its premises. The court also granted Ware Jackson’s motion to exclude the plaintiff’s expert as unqualified to opine on the premises owner’s knowledge. The litigation team included Paul Smith, Michelle Blair, Margaret Bryant, and Simone Dawson.